Community Review - Scoring Rubric and Guiding Questions

Elements to consider in reviews

Community Reviewers must consider each of the following points as they undertake their reviews:

  • Assign for each criteria a score between 1 and 5 based on the scoring rubric below

  • For each of the three criteria a score and rationale for your score must be provided.

  • Each of the 3 sections should be considered and reviewed on its own merits; these sections are:

    • Impact ~ Does the proposal have the potential to provide a positive impact to Cardano?

    • Feasibility / Capability ~ Is the proposal feasible, and does the proposer have the capability to deliver the project successfully and manage Treasury funds properly?

    • Resources / Value for money ~ Does the proposal represent good value for money for the treasury and community?

  • Your rationale must explain the score you have given. If a rationale does not correspond with the score given, the review may be removed.

  • Any score without a rationale will be filtered out, and you will not be compensated.

  • Your rationale should help the voters decide, so make sure your considerations, scores and rationales are comprehensible.

  • Consider and communicate what additional information or improvements the proposer could include in future funds.

  • Be sure that you submit your review correctly.

Each of the three scored sections of a proposal (Impact, Feasibility, Value for Money) will be marked 1-5, where [1 Star ★] = very poor answer, through to [5 Stars ★★★★★] = great answer.

★ - VERY POOR ANSWER

★★ - POOR ANSWER

★★★ - ACCEPTABLE ANSWER

★★★★ - GOOD ANSWER

★★★★★ - GREAT ANSWER

Examples of scoring and rationales

The following are generic examples of scoring rationale for each of the three criteria. Please notethat these examples should not be directly copied; you should use your rationale when completing your review.

IMPACT

You are reviewing this project's positive impact on the Cardano Ecosystem.

Has this project clearly demonstrated in all aspects of the proposal that it will positively impact the Cardano Ecosystem?

Last updated